# How does a consumer maximize utility?

> Written with AI · [Consumer choice: utility, budgets and demand](https://lessoons.com/en/consumer-choice) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/consumer-choice/how-does-a-consumer-maximize-utility

A consumer maximizes utility by spending the whole budget so that the last shekel spent on each good brings the same extra satisfaction: (MU_(X))/(P_(X)) = (MU_(Y))/(P_(Y)). If one good gives more utility per shekel, moving money toward it raises total utility, until diminishing marginal utility makes the two equal again.

## The topic explained

### Utility per shekel

A buyer with a limited budget cannot have everything, so the question is how to divide it. Comparing marginal utility alone is not enough, because goods have different prices: a pita that adds 50 units of utility for ₪10 is worth less per shekel than a drink that adds 30 for ₪5. The right comparison is marginal utility per shekel, (MU)/P: the extra satisfaction each shekel buys.

Take Omer, with ₪35 to spend on pitas at ₪10 and drinks at ₪5 (numbers made up for this page). The table gives his marginal utility for each unit and divides it by the price. The first drink gives 6 units per shekel, the first pita 5, the second drink 5, and so on, each smaller than the last because of diminishing marginal utility.

### Spending one step at a time

A simple way to find the best choice is to spend step by step, each time on the unit that gives the most utility per shekel. Omer buys the first drink (6 per shekel), then the first pita and the second drink (5 each), then the second pita and the third drink (4 each). At that point he has spent exactly ₪35: two pitas and three drinks, with a total utility of 50 + 40 + 30 + 25 + 20 = 165.

At the end, the last shekel spent on pita and the last shekel spent on drinks both buy 4 units: (MU_(pita))/(P_(pita)) = 40/10 = 4 = 20/5 = (MU_(drink))/(P_(drink)) This is the utility-maximizing rule: spend the whole budget, and make marginal utility per shekel equal across goods. The chart compares other bundles that cost the same ₪35; both give only 150.

### Why the rule works, and what a price cut does

Suppose Omer bought the second pita's ₪10 worth of drinks instead: he would give up 40 units and gain 15 + 10 = 25. Whenever one good gives more utility per shekel than another, moving a shekel toward it raises total utility; only when the two are equal is there nothing left to gain.

Now let the price of pita fall to ₪5. The first pita now gives 50/5 = 10 units per shekel, more than any drink, so Omer moves spending toward pitas and buys more of them. That is the law of demand, seen from inside one person's budget.

### Common mistakes

Comparing marginal utility without dividing by the price. Equalizing total utility instead of marginal utility per shekel. Forgetting to spend the whole budget: equal ratios with money left over are not the best choice if more units would add utility. And treating the numbers as real measurements: they model the order of a person's preferences.

## Practice: maximizing utility

For 11th grade economics students. Use the tables and the chart on the sheet, show each calculation, then check against the answers.

1. **Write the utility-maximizing rule for two goods and say what else must hold.** — (MU_(X))/(P_(X)) = (MU_(Y))/(P_(Y)), and the whole budget must be spent.
2. **Books cost ₪20 and cinema tickets ₪10. Fill in the marginal utility per shekel in the table.** — Books: 5, 4, 3, 2. Tickets: 6, 5, 4, 3.
3. **With a budget of ₪70, which bundle maximizes utility? Show the last ratio of each good.** — Two books and three tickets: 2 · 20 + 3 · 10 = 70. Last ratios: 80/20 = 4 and 40/10 = 4.
4. **Fill in the total utility of each bundle that costs ₪70.** — 1 book, 5 tickets: 100 + 200 = 300. 2 books, 3 tickets: 180 + 150 = 330. 3 books, 1 ticket: 240 + 60 = 300.
5. **Use the chart. Why does bundle B, two pitas and three drinks, give the most utility, although every bundle costs ₪35?** — Because in it the last shekel spent on each good buys the same utility, 4; in the other bundles one good gives more per shekel than the other, so money could be moved to gain.
6. **Omer's last pita gives 3 units per shekel and his last drink 5. What should he do?** — Buy less pita and more drinks: each shekel moved from pita to drinks gives up about 3 units and gains about 5, until the ratios are equal.
7. **Write a short paragraph: how does the utility-maximizing rule explain the law of demand?** — A good answer says that when the price of a good falls, its marginal utility per shekel rises above that of other goods, so the consumer moves spending toward it and buys more, until the ratios are equal again: a lower price, a larger quantity demanded.

## Common questions

### What is the utility maximization rule?

Spend the whole budget so that the marginal utility per shekel is the same for every good: MU of X divided by the price of X equals MU of Y divided by the price of Y.

### Why divide marginal utility by the price?

Because goods cost different amounts. A good that adds more utility may still be a worse buy if it costs much more; utility per shekel puts goods on the same scale.

### What is consumer equilibrium?

The choice at which the consumer cannot raise total utility by moving money between goods: the budget is spent and marginal utility per shekel is equal across goods.

### What happens if marginal utility per shekel is not equal?

Moving a shekel from the good with the lower ratio to the good with the higher one raises total utility, until diminishing marginal utility makes the ratios equal.

### Do people really calculate marginal utility per shekel?

Not in numbers. The rule is a model of how a careful buyer weighs whether one more of something is worth its price compared with other uses of the money.
