# How do scientists know the climate is changing?

> Written with AI · [Geography: climate change and its effects](https://lessoons.com/en/climate-change) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/climate-change/how-do-scientists-know-the-climate-is-changing

Scientists know the climate is changing because many independent measurements agree. Thermometers show that 2024 was about 1.55°C warmer than the late nineteenth century. Air sampled on Mauna Loa since 1958 shows carbon dioxide rising every year, ice cores show it is far above any level of recent millennia, and tide gauges show the sea about 20 cm higher than in 1901.

## The topic explained

### Thermometers since 1850

The most direct evidence is temperature. Weather stations on land and measurements from ships at sea have been gathered into global records since 1850. Several separate teams, among them NASA, NOAA, the British Met Office with the University of East Anglia, and Berkeley Earth, each build their own record from the raw readings, with their own methods. Their results agree closely. The World Meteorological Organization combined six such datasets and found that 2024 was about 1.55°C warmer than the average of 1850 to 1900, and that the ten years from 2015 to 2024 were the ten warmest on record. Since 1975 the warming has run at roughly 0.15 to 0.20°C per decade.

A common misreading is to point to a cold winter as proof that nothing is happening. Weather is what happens on a given day; climate is the average over thirty years or more. One cold season does not change a trend measured over decades.

### The Keeling curve

In March 1958 the American scientist Charles David Keeling began measuring carbon dioxide on Mauna Loa, a volcano in Hawaii chosen because it lies far from continents, factories and forests that could distort the readings. The measurements have never stopped. The yearly average was 317 parts per million (ppm) in 1960 and 427 ppm in 2025, and the rise is getting faster: about 1.7 ppm a year on average since 1960, about 2.6 a year in the last five years. The graph of these readings is known as the Keeling curve.

### The yearly breath of the planet

Look closely at the monthly readings and the curve is a wave, rising and falling by about 6 ppm every year. Most of the world's land plants are in the Northern Hemisphere. In its spring and summer they grow and take carbon dioxide out of the air; in autumn and winter leaves fall and decay and give it back. The wave rides on a line that keeps climbing.

The wave matters for two reasons. It shows the instrument is sensitive enough to see the living planet breathe, and it warns against a mistake: comparing a summer reading with a winter one can show a fall that is only the season. The trend is read from year to year, not from month to month.

### Many lines of evidence

Ice adds a long view. Air bubbles trapped in the ice of Greenland and Antarctica are samples of old atmosphere, and they show carbon dioxide between about 275 and 285 ppm for thousands of years before the nineteenth century, far below today's level. Tide gauges and satellites show the sea about 20 cm higher in 2018 than in 1901. Glaciers shrink, and spring comes earlier for many plants and animals. Scientists trust the conclusion because these measurements are independent of one another, made with different instruments by different teams, and they all point the same way. On the bagrut, name at least two kinds of evidence and say what each one measures.

## Practice: the evidence for climate change

For 12th grade geography students. Use the timeline, graphs and table printed on the sheet to answer each question, then check your answers.

1. **Fill in the two hidden events in the timeline.** — 1958: Keeling starts the carbon dioxide record on Mauna Loa. 2013: carbon dioxide passes 400 parts per million.
2. **Carbon dioxide at Mauna Loa was 316.91 ppm in 1960, 414.21 ppm in 2020 and 427.35 ppm in 2025. Calculate the average rise per year from 1960 to 2025 and from 2020 to 2025. What do you conclude?** — 1960 to 2025: (427.35 - 316.91) ÷ 65 ≈ 1.70 ppm a year. 2020 to 2025: (427.35 - 414.21) ÷ 5 ≈ 2.63 ppm a year. The rise is getting faster.
3. **Explain why the curve in the graph goes up and down every year while the straight line keeps rising.** — Plants in the Northern Hemisphere, where most land plants are, take carbon dioxide out of the air as they grow in spring and summer and release it as leaves decay in autumn and winter: a swing of about 6 ppm. The straight line is the trend from burning fossil fuels, which keeps rising year after year.
4. **A student compares a reading from May with one from the following October and says carbon dioxide is falling. Explain the mistake.** — The two readings fall in different parts of the yearly cycle, so the drop is only the season, as plants in the Northern Hemisphere take up carbon dioxide in summer. A trend must be read by comparing the same season, or yearly averages, across years.
5. **Fill in the two hidden cells of the table.** — Thermometers: 2024 was about 1.55°C warmer than 1850 to 1900. Tide gauges: the sea was about 20 cm higher in 2018 than in 1901.
6. **Explain the difference between weather and climate, and why one cold winter does not disprove global warming.** — Weather is the state of the air on a given day or week; climate is the average over thirty years or more. A cold winter is weather. Warming is a trend over decades, and the ten warmest years on record were 2015 to 2024.
7. **Why do scientists trust the conclusion more because several kinds of evidence point the same way?** — Each kind of measurement has its own instruments, methods and possible errors. Thermometers, air samples, ice cores and tide gauges are independent of one another, so it is very unlikely that all of them would be wrong in the same direction.

## Common questions

### What is the Keeling curve?

The Keeling curve is the graph of carbon dioxide measured on Mauna Loa in Hawaii since 1958, started by Charles David Keeling. It rises every year, from 317 ppm in 1960 to 427 ppm in 2025, with a small wave each year from the growth and decay of plants.

### How much has the Earth warmed?

According to the World Meteorological Organization, 2024 was about 1.55°C warmer than the average of 1850 to 1900, the warmest year on record, with a margin of about 0.13°C either way.

### How do ice cores show past climate?

As snow piles up on the ice sheets of Greenland and Antarctica it traps bubbles of air. Drilling out a core and analyzing the bubbles gives samples of the atmosphere from long ago, layer by layer.

### Why was Mauna Loa chosen for measuring carbon dioxide?

Mauna Loa is a high volcano in the middle of the Pacific Ocean, far from continents, factories and forests. Air there is well mixed and shows the state of the whole atmosphere, not of a nearby city.
