# What did the Maharal say about exile?

> Written with AI · [Jewish Thought: The Classical Thinkers](https://lessoons.com/en/classical-jewish-thinkers) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-11 · https://lessoons.com/en/classical-jewish-thinkers/what-did-the-maharal-say-about-exile

The Maharal of Prague argued in Netzach Yisrael (1599) that exile is a departure from the natural order: the Jewish people out of its place, scattered and ruled by others. What is unnatural cannot last forever, so exile itself, he wrote, is a clear proof that redemption will come (Netzach Yisrael, chapter 1).

## The topic explained

### Who was the Maharal, and why begin with exile?

The Maharal (from Morenu ha-Rav Loew, our teacher Rabbi Loew) was Rabbi Judah Loew ben Bezalel. Born in the early 16th century (the exact year is unknown), he served as rabbi in Mikulov, Poznań and Prague, and died in Prague in 1609. His book Netzach Yisrael (The Eternity of Israel), printed in Prague in 1599, is about exile and redemption, and it begins with exile: a thing is truly known from its opposite, just as the Passover Haggadah begins with disgrace and ends with praise.

Then comes his bold claim: “כי הגלות בעצמו הוא ראיה והוכחה ברורה על הגאולה” (exile itself is a clear sign and proof of the redemption, Netzach Yisrael, chapter 1). A common mistake is to read this as comfort alone. The Maharal is building an argument, and he wants it judged as one.

### Three ways exile breaks the order

“כי אין ספק כי הגלות הוא שנוי ויציאה מן הסדר” (there is no doubt that exile is a change and a departure from the order), he writes, “שהשם יתברך סדר כל אומה במקומה הראוי לה” (for God set every nation in the place fitting for it), and the place of Israel is the Land of Israel. Exile breaks that order three ways. It takes the people out of its place. It scatters a people that is one: “וכמו כן הפיזור אינו דבר טבעי” (likewise, scattering is not natural), for in nature things gather, as he quotes: “כָּל־הַנְּחָלִים הֹלְכִים אֶל־הַיָּם” (all the rivers go to the sea, Ecclesiastes 1:7). And it puts one nation under another, though “כי השם יתברך ברא כל אומה ואומה לעצמה” (God created every nation for itself).

The third point is not about Israel alone: “כי ראוי שתהיה כל אומה בני חורין” (every nation ought to be free). The order he describes is a world where each people has its place, its unity and its freedom.

### The argument from nature

The argument rests on the physics of his day, inherited from Aristotle, in which every element has a natural place: fire rises, earth falls. Things forced out of their natural place cannot stay where they do not belong: “רק הם חוזרים למקומם הטבעי” (they only return to their natural place). Force a flame downward, his example runs, and it will not stay. And “שאין עומד בתמידות רק הדברים הטבעיים” (nothing endures forever but what is natural).

If exile lasted forever, the unnatural would become natural, which he calls impossible. Hence “ולכך מן הגלות נוכל לעמוד על הגאולה” (from the exile we can come to know the redemption). Sin explains the exile, but only “כי אם לפי שעה במקרה החטא” (for a time, through the accident of sin). He finds the same idea in the midrash on “יָדֹעַ תֵּדַע” (know for certain, Genesis 15:13): “ידוע שאני מפזרן תדע שאני מקבצן” (know that I scatter them, know that I gather them).

### How to read the argument today

Modern physics has no natural places, so the image no longer works as science. Readers respond in different ways: some read the argument as a claim about the nature of the people, not about physics; others see it as faith given the shape of a proof. It also cannot say when: by the time he wrote, the exile had lasted more than fifteen centuries.

Religious and secular readers alike may hear in his words the idea that every people belongs in its own place and deserves to be free; the Maharal himself spoke of the divine order of the world, not of a political plan. A good answer sets out the premises, the conclusion and one objection, in his words.

## Practice: the Maharal on exile and redemption

For 11th grade students of Jewish thought. Read the quotations printed on the sheet, answer each question, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Who was the Maharal, and in which book does he write about exile and redemption?** — Rabbi Judah Loew ben Bezalel, rabbi in Mikulov, Poznań and Prague, who died in Prague in 1609. He writes about exile and redemption in Netzach Yisrael, printed in Prague in 1599.
2. **The Maharal writes: “כי הגלות בעצמו הוא ראיה והוכחה ברורה על הגאולה” (exile itself is a clear sign and proof of the redemption, chapter 1). What is surprising about this claim?** — Exile is usually taken as a sign that redemption is far away. The Maharal turns this around: because exile is unnatural, exile itself proves that it will end.
3. **The Maharal writes that things forced out of their natural place cannot stay there: “רק הם חוזרים למקומם הטבעי” (they only return to their natural place). Fill in the last box of the table.** — Israel, when forced from its natural place, returns to it: the people will return to the Land of Israel, which is the redemption.
4. **Fill in the missing premise of the argument. Use the quotation “שאין עומד בתמידות רק הדברים הטבעיים” (nothing endures forever but what is natural).** — 2: what is unnatural cannot last forever. Only the natural endures, so exile, which is unnatural, will end.
5. **List the three ways exile departs from the order of the world, according to the Maharal, and for each say what the order requires.** — Out of its place: every nation belongs in its place, and Israel in the Land of Israel. Scattered: one nation belongs together. Ruled by others: every nation ought to be free.
6. **Sin explains the exile, but only “כי אם לפי שעה במקרה החטא” (for a time, through the accident of sin). How does sin fit into the argument without breaking it?** — Sin can cause a departure from the order for a time, as a punishment. It cannot make that departure permanent, because what leaves the order does not endure forever.
7. **He writes: “כי לשון 'גלה' ו'גאל' אותיות שניהם שוות” (the words gola, exile, and geula, redemption, have the same letters). What does the Maharal learn from the two words?** — Both words share their letters, and the alef that geula adds in the middle stands for oneness: redemption gathers the scattered into one. Exile itself leads to redemption.
8. **Write a paragraph: does the argument from nature convince you? Give the premises and the conclusion, one quotation from this sheet, one objection and a reply.** — A good answer sets out both premises and the conclusion, quotes for example “nothing endures forever but what is natural”, raises an objection (physics has changed; the exile lasted centuries) and replies to it (for him nature is God's order), without dismissing either view.

## Common questions

### Who was the Maharal of Prague?

Rabbi Judah Loew ben Bezalel, one of the great rabbis and thinkers of the 16th century. He served as rabbi in Mikulov, Poznań and Prague, died in Prague in 1609, and wrote, among other works, Netzach Yisrael, Gevurot Hashem and Gur Aryeh.

### What is Netzach Yisrael about?

Netzach Yisrael, printed in Prague in 1599, is about exile and redemption: why the people went into exile, what exile means, and why it cannot last forever. It begins with exile, because in his view redemption is understood only through its opposite.

### Did the Maharal create the golem?

That is a later legend. The story was first tied to him in print in 1834, more than two hundred years after his death, and scholars note it has no trace in his writings. His thought is learned from his books, such as Netzach Yisrael.

### Why is exile a proof of redemption for the Maharal?

Because exile departs from the natural order, and what is unnatural cannot last forever. If exile lasted for good, the unnatural would become natural, which in his view is impossible.

### What do the Hebrew words for exile and redemption have in common?

The Maharal points out that gola (exile) and geula (redemption) share their letters, and that geula adds an alef in the middle. The alef stands for oneness, so redemption is the gathering of a scattered people into one.
