# What is urbanism as a way of life?

> Written with AI · [Sociology: the city and community](https://lessoons.com/en/city-and-community) · Grade 11 · 2026-11-14 · https://lessoons.com/en/city-and-community/what-is-urbanism-as-a-way-of-life

Urbanism as a way of life is Louis Wirth's 1938 theory that the city itself shapes how people live. A city is large, dense and socially varied, he argued, so its people meet mostly as strangers, in brief, impersonal contacts, and family and neighborhood ties weaken. Herbert Gans later showed close-knit urban villages inside the city.

## The topic explained

### Wirth's question and his three features

In 1938 the Chicago sociologist Louis Wirth published Urbanism as a Way of Life in the American Journal of Sociology. He wanted a sociological definition of the city and an account of the way of life it produces. A city, he argued, is a large, dense and permanent settlement of socially varied people, and each of the three features has its effect. Size means that no one can know most of the people around them. Density puts bodies close together while minds keep their distance. Heterogeneity, the mix of origins, classes and beliefs, breeds tolerance but weakens shared norms.

The misreading to avoid: Wirth did not say that city people are worse than villagers. He described what the structure of the city tends to do to relations between people.

### From primary to secondary contacts

The central effect is the substitution of secondary for primary contacts. A primary contact, the kind found in a family or a village, involves the whole person and lasts. A secondary contact involves one role: the cashier, the bus driver, the client. Wirth described urban contacts as impersonal, superficial, brief and segmental. As a result, he argued, kinship bonds and the neighborhood weaken, and formal control, the police and the law, replaces the watchful eyes of neighbors.

Picture buying bread in a village where the baker knows your grandmother, and buying it in a city supermarket from someone you will never see again. Both are exchanges; only one is a relationship.

### A continuum, not two boxes

Following Max Weber's method of the ideal type, Wirth treated the rural and the urban as two ends of a continuum. The bigger, denser and more varied a settlement, the more urban its way of life should be. A small town lies between the village and the metropolis, and a city neighborhood can be more village-like than a suburb.

Israel offers a clear range. In a kibbutz of a few hundred members, almost every contact is primary: people work, eat and raise children together and know each other's families. In a town of tens of thousands, many contacts are already secondary. In a metropolis such as Tel Aviv, most daily meetings, on the train, in the office tower or at the supermarket, are with strangers in a single role. Wirth would predict a more urban way of life at each step along the way.

### Gans and the urban villagers

Herbert Gans tested the theory in the field. In The Urban Villagers (1962) he studied Boston's West End, a working-class Italian-American neighborhood that the city was clearing as a slum, and found close-knit families, friends and neighbors: a village inside the city. Gans argued that how people live depends more on their class and stage of life than on the size or density of the city, and later found that suburbs were not uniform either.

A strong answer sets out Wirth's three features and the shift to secondary contacts, then weighs them against Gans's evidence and asks which fits a neighborhood the student knows.

Notice that the two did not simply disagree about facts. Wirth asked what the city as a whole tends to produce; Gans looked closely at particular groups within it. Both kinds of question are needed: the city's size and variety set the stage, while class, origin and stage of life shape how each group plays its part on it.

## Practice: urbanism as a way of life

For 11th grade students of sociology. Answer each question from what is printed on the sheet, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Name Wirth's three features of the city.** — Size, density and heterogeneity (social variety).
2. **What follows from heterogeneity, according to the table?** — Many groups and tolerance, along with weaker shared norms.
3. **Complete the table: in a secondary contact, whom do you see?** — One role of the person, such as the cashier or the bus driver, not the whole person.
4. **Is a talk with a bank clerk about a loan a primary or a secondary contact? Explain.** — Secondary: it involves one role (clerk and client), is brief and impersonal.
5. **What lies between the village and the big city on Wirth's continuum?** — The small town: less urban than the city, more urban than the village.
6. **What did Gans find in Boston's West End, and how does it challenge Wirth?** — An urban village: close-knit families and neighbors inside the city. It suggests that class and stage of life, not the city itself, shape how people live.
7. **In a city neighborhood, families have lived on the same street for three generations and meet at the same synagogue. Use Wirth and Gans to explain the case.** — A good answer notes that the case fits Gans's urban village rather than Wirth's prediction, explains that Wirth expected size, density and variety to weaken such ties, and suggests what keeps them here (shared origin, class, religion, long residence).

## Common questions

### Who wrote Urbanism as a Way of Life?

Louis Wirth, a sociologist of the Chicago School, who published it in the American Journal of Sociology in 1938, ten years after his book The Ghetto.

### What are secondary contacts?

Relations in which people meet in one role only, briefly and impersonally, such as a customer and a cashier. Wirth argued that they replace primary contacts in the city.

### What is an urban village?

Herbert Gans's term for a close-knit community inside a city. He found one among Italian-American working-class families in Boston's West End and described it in The Urban Villagers (1962).

### What is the rural to urban continuum?

The idea that settlements range from the rural to the urban rather than falling into two boxes, so the way of life changes by degree with size, density and variety.

### Is Wirth's theory still accepted?

In part. His features of the city are still used, but studies like Gans's showed that close communities survive in cities, and that class and stage of life explain much of how people live.
