# What are the four principles of bioethics?

> Written with AI · [Biotechnology: bioethics and the regulation of research](https://lessoons.com/en/bioethics-and-regulation) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-13 · https://lessoons.com/en/bioethics-and-regulation/what-are-the-four-principles-of-bioethics

The four principles of bioethics are respect for autonomy, letting people make informed decisions about themselves; non-maleficence, avoiding harm; beneficence, acting for people's good; and justice, sharing benefits and burdens fairly. Tom Beauchamp and James Childress set them out in 1979, and they are used to think through hard cases in medicine and biotechnology, though they guide a decision rather than make it.

## The topic explained

### Four questions for a hard case

What are the four principles of bioethics, and where do they come from? In 1979 the philosophers Tom Beauchamp and James Childress, both at Georgetown University, published Principles of Biomedical Ethics. They proposed four principles that people of different religions and philosophies could share, placed between grand moral theories and everyday moral sense. The same year, the Belmont Report in the United States set out three similar principles for research on people.

Respect for autonomy asks that a capable person be allowed to decide about their own body and data, after being told what they need to know. Non-maleficence asks that we avoid causing harm. Beneficence asks more: that we act for a person's good, by preventing harm and helping. Justice asks that benefits, risks and costs be shared fairly between people. A common misreading is that the four form a ranking, autonomy first. They have no fixed order; each case decides how much each weighs. In real cases the principles also touch: informed consent, for example, protects autonomy and helps prevent harm.

### Each principle in biotechnology

In biotechnology every principle has a familiar face. Autonomy is behind informed consent before a genetic test or a clinical trial; in Israel it is anchored in the Patient's Rights Law of 1996. Non-maleficence is why a new gene therapy is tested first for safety, in few people, before anything else. Beneficence drives research into treatments for conditions that had none. Justice asks who will be able to afford a gene therapy that costs a fortune, and whether trials include the groups who will use the treatment. In this way the principles turn from abstract names into questions that a laboratory, a committee and a state must answer.

### Applying them to a case

Consider an invented case. A woman has her genome sequenced to find the cause of a skin condition, and the laboratory also finds a variant that raises the risk of a serious illness later in life. She had said in advance that she wanted only results about her skin. Respect for autonomy says her choice should be honored. Non-maleficence warns that unwanted news can cause distress. Beneficence notes that knowing could lead to early checks. Justice reminds us that her relatives may carry the variant too. For this reason laboratories usually ask people before sequencing which kinds of findings they want to receive, so that the choice is made calmly in advance rather than at the moment a result arrives.

The principles do not give the answer; they show where the tension lies, here between autonomy and beneficence, and force reasons. A strong bagrut answer states the facts, asks each principle's question, names the conflict, weighs it with reasons, and reaches a position, while acknowledging the other side. A weak answer names the four principles and stops.

### Their critics

The approach has critics. The name principlism was coined by two of them, Danner Clouser and Bernard Gert, who argued that four principles without a theory to rank them cannot settle a conflict. Others say the principles become a checklist used mechanically, or that they place the individual's autonomy above family and community in a way not every culture shares. Supporters, among them Raanan Gillon, answer that the principles were never meant as an algorithm but as a shared language for reasoning, and Beauchamp and Childress have revised their book over many editions in reply. In a bagrut answer, mentioning a criticism shows that the principles are a tool to be used with judgment, not a formula.

## Practice: the four principles of bioethics

For 12th grade biotechnology students. Answer each question in full sentences, then compare with the answers.

1. **Complete the hidden questions: what do beneficence and justice ask?** — Beneficence: are we acting for the person's good, preventing harm and helping? Justice: are benefits, risks and costs shared fairly between people?
2. **What is the difference between non-maleficence and beneficence?** — Non-maleficence asks us to avoid causing harm. Beneficence asks more, that we act positively for a person's good, by preventing harm and helping.
3. **Match each example to a principle: a patient signs a consent form after an explanation; a trial stops when side effects appear; a health system debates who gets an expensive therapy.** — Consent: respect for autonomy. Stopping the trial: non-maleficence. Who gets the therapy: justice.
4. **Fill in step 3 of the method and explain why it is the heart of the analysis.** — Find where the principles conflict. Most hard cases are hard because two principles point different ways, and the answer must explain how that conflict is weighed.
5. **Complete the hidden cell, and name the two principles in sharpest tension in the sequencing case.** — Non-maleficence: unwanted news may cause distress. The sharpest tension is between respect for autonomy, honoring her choice not to know, and beneficence, the chance that knowing could help.
6. **State one criticism of the four-principles approach and one reply to it.** — Criticism: without a theory to rank them, the principles cannot settle a conflict, and they risk becoming a checklist. Reply: they were meant as a shared language for reasoning, not an algorithm; judgment in each case does the weighing.
7. **Who set out the four principles, and in what year?** — Tom Beauchamp and James Childress, in Principles of Biomedical Ethics, first published in 1979.

## Common questions

### Which of the four principles is the most important?

None is first by rule. Beauchamp and Childress present them as equally weighty in principle, and in each case the reasons decide which should give way when they conflict.

### What is the difference between the four principles and the Belmont Report?

The Belmont Report of 1979 set three principles for research on people: respect for persons, beneficence and justice. The four principles cover medicine and research and separate non-maleficence from beneficence.

### How do I use the four principles in a bagrut answer?

State the facts, ask what each principle requires in this case, name where they conflict, weigh the conflict with reasons and reach a position, mentioning the strongest argument on the other side.

### What is principlism?

A name, given by critics, for the approach that reasons about cases with the four principles. Supporters prefer to call it the four-principles approach.

### Is informed consent the same as autonomy?

Informed consent is the practical rule that protects autonomy: a person agrees to a test, treatment or study only after understanding it and choosing freely.
