# What are the ethical issues in advertising?

> Written with AI · [Advertising and persuasion](https://lessoons.com/en/advertising-and-persuasion) · Grade 12 · 2026-11-11 · https://lessoons.com/en/advertising-and-persuasion/ethical-issues-in-advertising

The main ethical issues in advertising are misleading claims, ads disguised as content, advertising aimed at children, stereotypes and unrealistic body images, the promotion of harmful products such as tobacco, and the use of personal data. Defenders say advertising pays for free media and informs buyers; critics say it creates wants and can exploit the vulnerable. In Israel, laws and broadcasting rules set limits on it.

## The topic explained

### Two views of advertising

The ethical issues in advertising start with a basic disagreement. Its defenders point out that advertising pays for much of the media people get for free, from television channels to news sites, tells buyers about products and prices, and pushes firms to compete. Its critics answer that it can mislead, that it reaches people who cannot judge it, and that it creates wants rather than meeting them.

The economist John Kenneth Galbraith made the last argument in The Affluent Society (1958): he called it the dependence effect, the production of goods creating, through advertising, the very wants it then satisfies. Friedrich Hayek replied in 1961 that almost every want beyond food and shelter is learned from our surroundings, a taste for music or literature too, and that this does not make it less real. The bagrut asks students to set out both views and weigh them, not to declare a winner.

### Six questions an ad can raise

Misleading claims: a price that hides extra fees, a “from ₪99” that is really ₪199, a green claim with nothing behind it. Hidden ads: native advertising made to look like an article, or an influencer's post that does not say it was paid for. Children: young viewers may not tell an ad from a program or understand its aim. Body image: edited photos set a standard no real body meets. Harmful products: tobacco, alcohol and gambling, where the more an ad works, the more harm it may do. Privacy: ads targeted with personal data people never knowingly gave.

Persuasion is not the same as deception. An ad may appeal to emotion and show a product at its best; it crosses an ethical line when it states something false, hides what matters or exploits someone who cannot judge it.

### How Israel regulates advertising

The Consumer Protection Law of 1981 forbids misleading a consumer on any material matter and applies this to advertising. It also treats an ad that a reasonable person might not recognize as an ad as misleading, even if what it says is true, and it forbids advertising likely to mislead a minor or exploit a minor's age and inexperience. Since 1994 the Second Authority for Television and Radio has had its own ethics rules for television and radio advertising.

Two laws target particular harms. The model weight law of 2012, in force from January 2013, bars models with a body mass index below 18.5 from ads and requires an ad whose model was edited to look thinner to say so, in a notice of at least 7% of the ad. Tobacco advertising has been restricted since 1983; an amendment passed at the end of 2018 banned it in most media, with the printed press the main exception when it passed, and plain packaging followed in January 2020. This is a summary for study, not legal advice.

### How to judge an ad

To analyze an ad ethically, ask four questions: who is the audience, what exactly does the ad claim, what does it leave out, and who could be harmed. Then name the rule or principle at stake and set out the argument on each side. A made-up example: an influencer praises a face cream and mentions in small print at the end that the brand sent it. Is the disclosure clear enough for her young followers?

The most common mistakes are writing that “all advertising lies”, which ignores honest ads, and confusing an ad you dislike with an unethical one. A good answer is specific about the claim, the audience and the harm.

## Practice: ethical issues in advertising

For 12th grade students of communications. All cases on this sheet are made up. Answer each question from what is printed here, then check your work against the answers.

1. **Explain Galbraith's dependence effect and Hayek's reply, one sentence each.** — Galbraith (1958): production creates, through advertising, the wants it then satisfies, so those wants are not truly the consumer's own. Hayek (1961): almost all wants beyond basic needs are learned from our surroundings, which does not make them less real or less important.
2. **Name the ethical issue in each made-up case in the table.** — Superpower cereal for kids: advertising to children (a claim a child cannot judge). Paid post, no ad label: a hidden ad. Thinned photo, no notice: body image (an edited photo). From ₪99, really ₪199: a misleading claim.
3. **An influencer is paid to praise a phone and says only true things about it, but does not say she was paid. Why can Israel's Consumer Protection Law treat the post as misleading?** — Because the law treats an ad that a reasonable person might not recognize as an ad as misleading, even if its content is accurate. Followers think it is a personal opinion, and that hides a material fact: she was paid.
4. **Complete the timeline: which Israeli rules on advertising date from 1981 and 2012?** — 1981: the Consumer Protection Law, which forbids misleading advertising. 2012: the model weight law (in force from January 2013), which bars underweight models and requires a notice when a photo was edited to make a model look thinner.
5. **Rewrite this made-up slogan so that it is honest and still persuasive: “Lose 10 kg in a week, guaranteed.”** — A good answer removes the false promise and the guarantee, and keeps a real benefit, for example: “A filling breakfast with 200 calories, part of a balanced diet.” Any number must be true and checkable.
6. **Persuasion or deception? (a) A soft drink ad shows friends laughing at the beach. (b) A juice labeled “100% fruit” is half sugar water.** — (a) Persuasion: an emotional appeal, which is not false in itself. (b) Deception: a false factual claim on a material matter.
7. **Should television advertising aimed at children under 12 be banned? Write a short balanced answer with one argument on each side and your conclusion.** — A good answer gives an argument for a ban (young children may not understand that an ad aims to sell, so it can exploit them), an argument against (ads fund children's programs, parents decide what to buy, and honest ads can be allowed), and a reasoned conclusion that weighs the two.

## Common questions

### What is native advertising?

Native advertising is paid content made to look like the editorial content around it: an article on a news site, a post in a feed. It is ethical only when it is clearly labeled as sponsored, so that readers know who paid for it and why.

### What is the photoshop law in Israel?

It is the popular name of the 2012 law on weight in the modeling industry, in force from January 2013. It bars models with a body mass index below 18.5 from ads, and an ad whose model was edited to look thinner must say so in a notice of at least 7% of the ad.

### Is advertising to children allowed?

In Israel the Consumer Protection Law forbids advertising likely to mislead a minor, exploit a minor's age, naivety or inexperience, or encourage activity harmful to a minor's health. Broadcasting rules add limits of their own. Rules differ from country to country.

### What is greenwashing?

Greenwashing is presenting a product or a company as better for the environment than it really is, with vague words like eco or natural, a green design, or one small good act made to look like the whole picture. It is a kind of misleading claim.

### Is all persuasion in advertising unethical?

No. Showing a product at its best and appealing to real feelings are normal and legitimate. An ad becomes unethical when it states something false, hides a material fact, hides that it is an ad or exploits people who cannot judge it.
